Monday, August 19th is your last chance to tell Easttown's Supervisors not to implement a new Income Tax! Attend the meeting. August 19th at 7pm. Beaumont Elementary School.
An Earned Income Tax (EIT) is a tax is on salary, bonus, and all paid compensation. An EIT taxes the net profits of small businesses - restaurants, gas stations, retailers, medical and professional practices, manufacturers’ reps, etc. And it’s a new tax on hardworking people in our community who live or work someplace without an EIT - servers and kitchen staff in restaurants, car mechanics, nurses, doctors and teachers.
YES. The Earned Income Tax (EIT) of 0.5% will be imposed on all Easttown residents. This is in addition to the property taxes residents already pay - either directly as a homeowner or indirectly through rent paid to the owner of the property. If you are a renter in Easttown Township, this affects you too.
YES. The new EIT will be on top of property taxes - and property taxes will not only not be reduced, but could continue to rise.
YES. Even after a massive property tax increase of 34% in last year's budget, the Supervisors still want more of your money.
NOT REALLY. The NW Financial Group, LLC Revenue Study from May 2023 that the township is relying upon uses worker location data as of 2020. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, many more people have shifted from offices in places that charge EIT to work from home. Between people employed in non-EIT municipalities (Tredyffrin, Radnor, Lower Merion, Upper Merion, etc.) and people who work from home, this may be a NEW tax on more than 50% of Easttown residents in 2025.
LOTS OF NEW, UNSPECIFIED SPENDING.
The 0.5% EIT will generate about $4.4 million. The Supervisors have said that the EIT is critical to properly fund Easttown’s Fire/EMT services. Currently, the township spends about $1.3 million for this (funded by property taxes). In 2025, the Supervisors propose to increase funding for Fire/EMT services by $630k to about $1.9 million. Assuming that this 50% increase for Fire/EMT is justified, at most the Supervisors need $630k of new revenue, not $4.4 million.
What will they do with the rest of this taxpayer windfall? The remaining nearly $3.8 million of new annual revenue generated by the proposed EIT is for unspecified projects and includes Supervisor "wish list" items like a new township building, sidewalks and streetscapes, Town Square (s), recreational assets, meadows at Hilltop Park, and more.
IT EXPLODES. The township's current budget is approximately $8.3 million. The proposed 0.5% EIT will bring in $4.4 million - increasing the budget (and spending) by 55%. The problem is, while the Supervisors have said they need an extra $630k per year beyond current funding to support Fire/EMT services, they haven't really explained what they will do with the other $3.8 million (every year)!
YES - AND NO.
Using the township's pre-COVID, unreliable data, currently only 55% of Easttown residents pay an EIT to another municipality. So the tax will be new for 45% of township residents.
But for those who pay an EIT to Philadelphia (17%), the township receives NOTHING back. Which means that we would recoup money from only a small portion of those already paying elsewhere.
YES. There are many alternatives. Here are just a few examples:
1. An increased property transfer tax
Radnor and Tredyffrin both impose a 2.5% property transfer tax; Easttown's is only 2%.
In 2023, 104 homes sold in Easttown. If we had a 2.5% property transfer tax (instead of 2%) Easttown would have netted an additional $593,917.00 in revenue that year alone.
2. A Local Services Tax
Other local townships impose a Local Services Tax (LST) of $52 on everyone who works in their townships; Easttown could do the same. Using an average of 2016-2020, a $52 LST would have generated an additional $158,444 per year - and be dedicated to Fire/EMT services.
** Taken together, alternatives 1 and 2 would have raised more than the $630k the Supervisors say we need for increased Fire/EMT funding for 2025, and would have been about 40% of the ENTIRE Fire/EMT budget for 2025.
3. A Dedicated Fire/EMT Fee
There is strong community support to help fund our Fire/EMT through a dedicated fee for just that purpose (no extra Supervisor wish list items) rather than an unchecked new tax whose revenues far exceed the money needed to pay for these services.
***Taken with alternative 1 and 2, a dedicated Fire/EMT fee would be a reasonable amount.
4. Find Cost Savings
The Board has also refused to look at other cost saving measures such as allowing remote work to open up office space in the township building, or even renting empty commercial space in the township for certain departments to avoid building a new municipal facility. And there are certainly "wish list" items that Easttown can live without.
5. Other Ideas
In a township with so many residents, there are surely more ideas than just those mentioned above. If you have ideas, share them with the Supervisors.
Easttown Township's Board of Supervisors (BOS) have voted to officially advertise the creation of a new, earned income tax of 0.5% to be levied on all township residents - on top of the property taxes they already pay.
The BOS will make a final vote to create and impose this new tax on August 19th at their Board Meeting to be held at 7:00 pm at Beaumont Elementary School.
In 2023, the BOS considered an EIT but chose to table their discussion after hundreds of Easttown residents expressed their opposition at a special township meeting.
This year, hundreds of residents again came to a special township meeting and again expressed their opposition - but this time the Supervisors chose not to listen.
Now residents have one last chance to try and convince their elected officials NOT to impose the new income tax - either by contacting Supervisors before the August 19th meeting or by attending the August 19th meeting and expressing their opposition.
Make your voice heard. Contact the Supervisors today. Tell them that there are alternatives to a new tax on 45% of the community.
Email them, call them, send them a letter. Tell them that there are alternatives to a new tax on 45% of the community.
Erik Unger, Chair eunger@easttown.org
Michael Wacey, Vice Chair mwacey@easttown.org
Sean Axel saxel@easttown.org
Alex Bosco abosco@easttown.org
Susan LeBoutillier sleboutillier@easttown.org
610-687-3000
Easttown Township Supervisors
566 Beaumont Road
Devon, PA 19333
Documentation for the information on this website was taken primarily from the NW Financial Group, LLC Revenue Study, May 2023. This study was prepared to support the move by Easttown's Board of Supervisors towards an EIT. While there are numerous issues with numerical assumptions in this report, it was heavily relied upon and referred to by our Board of Supervisors. Information regarding the fire funding and Supervisor "wish list" of projects are also taken from township documents. All documents are publicly available.
June 17, 2024 BOS meeting (EIT Discussion from 25:00 to 1:03:00)
July 15, 2024 Special BOS meeting (EIT Discussion 2:42 to 2:11:50)
Copyright © 2024 NoEasttownEIT - All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.